The 2020 Portfolio Pro Critique Template

Image critique is not an easy task. It takes a while to write a thorough critique. We all benefit from giving and receiving critique and this is what this group is all about. A list of prompts follows for your consideration while constructing your critique. You are not required to answer all or any of these questions. However, considering the questions posed may assist you in writing a high quality critique. You are encouraged to take notes on what you see, how you react, what you like, and what you do not like. You may always choose to write a free form critique as long as the minimum word count is met.

Please note the following: Receiving critique is not as easy as it sounds. You might not be happy with the content. Even if you disagree, keep in mind that this is how another individual is seeing and responding to your work.

1. Post your image to the pool
2. Display the first image you want to critique in a new window or a separate tab
3. Possibly change to structured or free form by pressing one of the corresponding buttons
4. Use the web page input fields below to critique and grade an image (the critique input fields are marked with the text "Click to enter your critique" before you start using them)
5. When you have finished your critique and (optional) grades, click the HTML field at the bottom left and copy (CTRL-C) the content
6. Go to the photo you just critiqued, paste the HTML code into the comment field (CTRL-V) and click the "POST COMMENT" button
7. Do this for the 2 photos to the right of your own photo

Structured Free Form		Clear Form
Initial Impression:
		Points to consider: What do you see? What are the most impactful elements of the image? What does the photograph communicate to you? Are any emotions evoked? How do you engage with the image?
Visual Composition:
		Points to consider: Are any visual elements (color /tone /texture /shape /line /space /depth) effectively employed in the image? Do any principles of design (balance/movement/repetition/proportion/unity/emphasis) strengthen what is seen? Does the chosen perspective heighten the image? Does the overall composition enhance the subject or mood?
Technical Execution:
		Technical points to consider: Do the exposure choices enhance the image? Are the necessary elements sharp/clear? How does depth of field/bokeh affect the image? Is there any unnecessary noise or digital artifacts? Are the colors (or black/white conversation) presented effectively? Do the processing choices help the image succeed?
Aesthetic Considerations:
		Aesthetic points to consider: Does the image have expressive or artistic qualities? Is it unique, original, or innovative? Does the image transcend documentation? Has your reaction to the image changed after careful consideration? Does it work?
Total Impression:
HTML code to copy/paste into the Flickr photo comment field:		Critique Preview:
		element